Bernini’s First Important Statue

What is this? Who is that burly guy and why is he carrying an old man?

The burly guy is Aeneas, the legendary founder of Rome; and he’s caring his dad, Anchises. They are getting out of Troy, their home, as fast as they can because the city is on fire.
The little boy is Aeneas’ son, Ascanius.

What’s the old man carrying?

Those are the penates, the home-gods that watch over you. Every household had some in a niche in the hall. They were what you grabbed to take with you when you could take only one thing. They would protect you and your family.

Who made the statue?

Gian Lorenzo Bernini. He carved it when he was only twenty. It is in the Galleria Borghese, Rome.

But what is the story?

It is a side-story in the Trojan War legend, the subject of the Illiad, Homer’s great epic poem. The Greeks all knew this and many other stories from that idealized history of their country. The Greek version of this one ended with the flight of Aeneas, a prince of Troy, and his family.

Aeneas and his father as depicted on a Greek vase

When Rome was inventing its own history years later and looking for a founder, it took up this Aeneas thread. Roman historians thought they couldn’t do better than the old Greek legends. Monkeying the story of Ulysses, who after the Trojan War was kept wandering around the world because of the curse of an angry god, they said Aeneas and his family were made to wander around the Mediterranean after leaving Troy because of the curse of an angry goddess. The hero was not able to settle down until, after years, he reached Latium, the place that would become Rome. Anchises died along the way. Aeneas’s wife did too. Eventually Aeneas became king of the Latins and married a local princess.

But what is Bernini doing with this antique Greek/Roman story? Wasn’t he a Christian?

There was a religious revival in Italy in the seventeenth century when he lived. One of the stock themes of the Counter-Reformation was the triumph of faith over adversity. The old Roman hero had held onto those penates and believed in them and they guided his family safely through countless vicissitudes. He was just the example of piety toward God and toward parents that rulers were looking for. It was a cardinal—Scipione Borghese—who commissioned the statue.

It is an incredibly ambitious work for a sculptor not yet twenty years old. Bernini’s father, who was a master carver, probably helped him—and may be responsible for what now looks like its worst features.

Critics sometimes complain about the group’s troubling instability. They assume Bernini was trying to put figures together like this Rape of the Sabine Women by Giambologna and failed.

Giambologna’s figures show a spectacular upward, spiral movement. They might as well be dancers. Bernini’s group is not only not graceful, it is distressingly awkward. The old man sits very heavily on his son’s shoulders (he couldn’t sit like that for long) and seems about to come sliding down.

True. But the other signs of tension and instability in the statue show that Bernini was trying for just that effect. It was his way of dramatizing. Look at the base. The very least he could have done, say the critics, is to give the tottering group a flat, solid, place to stand. But Bernini goes and makes it rounded!

“I made it that way,” Bernini would say, “to suggest the debris from the burning home that Aeneas is trying not to stumble over. I wanted to give the viewer the feel of the precariousness of the situation by showing the precariousness of the stance. Remember: those men are walking in the dark.”

Well and good, say the critics. But a statue dare not look like it will fall—that’s anti-aesthetic. It troubles the viewer.

“Let him be troubled,” says Bernini. He would do a lot more troubling before he had carved his last statue.

The theme was always a hard one to depict with grace. Here is Rafael’s version.

Aeneas is carrying the old man fireman-style and really struggling with the weight.

Barocci’s version is wonderful illustration:

Bernini’s modelling of the two men’s contrasting bodies is the work of a genius.
But why did he stop with the faces? Why are they so inexpressive? The face of the old man might have been intended to show senility. But couldn’t Bernini have put some tension—some pluck or anxiety—something!—into Aeneas’ face? He is the star of the group, his is the face one consults right off to get a clue to understanding the work. Given Bernini’s aim to dramatize the story, isn’t that a flaw?

Some have noticed the similarity between this Aeneas and Michelangelo’s Risen Christ in Santa Maria sopra Minerva in Rome:

Did the young sculptor try so hard to copy Michelangelo’s famous Christ that he forgot that the face of the Savior did not fit his own figure?

You can be sure Bernini knew what he was doing. The little boy’s face shows fear very well. All the details of this and all Bernini’s works are well-thought-out. Maybe he was advised by his father or the Cardinal to illustrate dignity and courage and faith in this way. “The brave man doesn’t wear his concern on his face the way that little boy does,” perhaps they told him. “He strides through adversity with confidence and serenity.”

This entry was posted in art, art history, Baroque, Bernini, great artists, Greek art, Greek ceramic vessels, mannerism, Michelangelo, sculpture, stone carving and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to Bernini’s First Important Statue

  1. ivdanu – Quebec – Canadian visual artist of Romanian origin.
    ivdanu says:

    Oh, man! In Rafael’s version seems that Aenaeas is carrying Santa Claus on his back…

  2. wrjones
    wrjones says:

    Now a real art critic would say this is JUST an illustration. I can’t get my mind around the difficulty of doing something requireing this level of skill. I wish I had a few generations to learn stone carving.

  3. erikatakacs – Canada – I am a figurative sculptor working in paper pulp.
    erikatakacs says:

    Well, they’re leaving behind a burned down Troy and their home, and people they lost. Aeneas and his father are depressed more than anything at this moment. He doesn’t even feel the weight of his father yet, the pain is still raw. Maybe Bernini was trying to show their deep sorrow over losing everything. I saw the faces of people who lost everything in Katrina or the tsunami. There wasn’t much drama, they were just sad and didn’t have much to say.
    Great work, especially considering he was so young. He shows great restraint in this one compared to his David.

  4. This is a great work and beautifully argued swallows. The question of the lack of anxiety or any discernable expression on the faces begs the need to re examine other works by him and others. I found the facial expression of Pierre Puget’s athlete being bitten by a lion somewhat an understatement!

    I wonder (only) sometimes if expression on faces reduces the aesthetic value or even cheapens the work. If you were to do this subject what expressions would you give them?

  5. 100swallows says:

    Danu: now don’t you be nasty. Bernini has Anchises wear that funny cap too. Do you think that is the real color Rafael painted him? So ugly yellow?

  6. 100swallows says:

    Bill: There are few people living today who could carve this figure in marble. Giambologna’s carving job is also impressive, don’t you think? I don’t know how he managed to hammer those fingers and those flying arms and hands, even waiting until they were almost finished before eliminating the support, without breaking them. It is a miracle that those figures are still intact. Some would say such detail is a mistreatment of the stone.

  7. 100swallows says:

    Erika: That’s good about the sorrow over their loss. But isn’t the statue illustrating their flight? That’s not when they would have put on the face of sorrow and contemplation. At that moment they were running for their lives.

  8. 100swallows says:

    Robert: I would show at least some sort of determination in Aeneas’s face. I agree that a grimace or otherwise contorted face (such as Bernini made in his David or in an early study of a grin) would have banalized the work. But there are two faces here and neither of them says much, which is a pity.
    I wouldn’t like to see Puget’s athlete actually howl.

  9. zeladoniac – Debby Kaspari travels the world with sketchbook and binoculars, drawing and painting in wild and not-so-wild landscapes. Norman, Oklahoma is her home base, and she lives there with her tropical ecologist husband and a mackerel tabby named Gizmo.
    zeladoniac says:

    The faces may be impassive; I read them as stoic. When I saw this piece at the Borghese I was overcome with pity for the old man. Bernini put the emotion in the bodies, especially in the withered limbs, the sagging belly, the hand on the son’s shoulder trying desperately to steady himself and not fall to the ground. The only thing I didn’t get, not knowing the story, was the object he was holding, the penate. Thank you for the enlightening history lesson.

    While there I was taken with how he used hands as focal points. The shaky hand on the shoulder of Aeneas, Pluto’s hands digging lustfully into Proserpina’s flesh and Apollo’s hand possessively placed on Daphne’s hip. Hands convey emotion, too. Bernini was brilliant with those details.

  10. 100swallows says:

    Zeladoniac: I guess you are right–that those faces were meant to show stoic resignation. And I will pay more attention to the hands now. Thanks.

  11. Andre Cidade says:

    What a shameful way to describe Rome’s great effort to find their origins:

    “When Rome was inventing its own history years later and looking for a founder, it took up this Aeneas thread. Roman historians thought they couldn’t do better than the old Greek legends. ”

    Desperately ignorant, I’m afraid…

    • 100swallows says:

      Andre Cidade: Shameful? Rome’s effort may be great but it isn’t holy and, now that the emperors are gone and Virgil and Livy have received their wreaths, I think we can remain sitting while hearing or repeating their stories.

Leave a ReplyCancel reply